Key Points

North Carolina licenses come in 3 tiers: Limited, Intermediate, and Unlimited, and the tier should fit the size of your project.
Paying for pre-construction can be a good sign, because that's the work that lets a fixed-price remodeler guarantee your price.
Ask for a certificate of insurance that names you as an additional insured, and get it in writing that every subcontractor carries workers' compensation.

Picture sitting across the table from the third remodeler you’ve interviewed this month. Every one of them says the right things, and every one of them has beautiful photos. How do you tell them apart before you sign something that big?

You’ll learn:

  • Whether a remodeler’s size and license fit your project
  • What a good track record looks like
  • Why paying for pre-construction can be a good sign
  • What a contract should spell out
  • How to check on subcontractors and insurance
  • How a remodeler should handle surprise costs

Is This Firm the Right Size for My Project?

A firm is the right size when its starting prices, its license tier, and its project managers’ workload fit your job. Some projects fit a high-end remodeler, and some fit a smaller crew better.

These 3 questions will tell you which kind you’re talking to:

  • Where do their projects start? Our whole-home remodels start at about $350,000. We don’t have a minimum project size, but on whole-home and addition work, we aren’t competitively priced on projects under $150,000.
  • What license tier do they hold? In North Carolina, the tiers are Limited, Intermediate, and Unlimited, and each step up requires stronger proof of financial stability. You can look up a remodeler by the owner’s name or the firm’s name on the North Carolina Licensing Board for General Contractors website. Check that their tier covers the size of your project.
  • How many jobs does each project manager run at once? That number tells you how much time they’ll have for your job. Ours run 3 to 4 at the most.

How Do I Check a Remodeler’s Experience and Track Record?

Ask how long they’ve been doing this work. The experience behind our in-home consultations goes back almost 15 years, about 8 of them at another building company before Watershed Builders started. Along the way, we’ve seen hundreds of remodeling projects in Charlotte and Lake Norman.

Then look at what a remodeler has actually finished, and find one who shows projects that look like yours. If you’re planning a large interior remodel and the company mostly builds decks and covered porches, that may not be the best fit because interiors bring plumbing, electrical, and structural work.

Finishes matter, too. If you want a higher-end look and the photos show finishes that aren’t quite there, that’s a yellow flag. If you want a more modest remodel and the portfolio is all high-end work, have that conversation early.

Kitchen with blue base cabinets, white upper cabinets, open wood shelves, and woven stools at a white peninsula.

This kitchen was one part of our whole-home remodel in Historic Dilworth, and the final price for the whole job, signed in May 2023, was $349,950.

Last, read their Google reviews, all of them, and look for patterns.


Does the Contractor Charge for Pre-Construction, and Is That a Good Sign?

Paying a remodeler before you’ve signed a construction contract can feel backward. We think it’s a good sign.

Pre-construction is where the final costs get worked out, and for a fixed-price remodeler like us, it’s the work that lets us put a guaranteed price on your job. Ours costs 1% of the low end of your preliminary budget, and that money goes toward your construction cost.

A big part of that work is your selections, like cabinetry, countertops, tile, plumbing fixtures, and lighting. We politely require them up front.

Ask the other remodelers you’re talking to whether they do the same, or let you decide as you go.


What Should the Contract Spell Out Before I Sign?

The contract should spell out your scope of work with your finishes described in detail, what can still change the price, and the warranty.

When you lay 2 proposals side by side, they can look quite different. There’s no standard way for remodelers to present pricing, so compare what each one includes, not just the total.

We price as a lump sum, so you get a scope of work with the price at the bottom of the page. However a remodeler prices it, the scope should describe your finishes in detail. If one proposal just says “cabinets” and the other says “flush inset cabinetry,” only the second one tells you what you’re really paying for.

Double vanity with gray inset cabinetry, a marble countertop, a long black-framed mirror, and a hexagon marble floor.

This primary bathroom cabinetry in our whole-home remodel in Providence Plantation has flush inset cabinets. It costs about 25% more than other cabinetry, so 2 proposals that both just say “cabinets” could be pricing very different cabinets.

2 more things belong in the contract:

  • A price that holds. Ours is guaranteed for everything documented in the contract, plans, or selections. We do have allowances, which are a set amount for an item not yet chosen, that can still move depending on what gets picked.
  • A warranty. Ours covers our workmanship for 1 year from the final building inspection, plus the manufacturer warranties.

Who Vets the Subcontractors, and What Happens If Work Is Substandard?

Your remodeler should vet the plumbers, electricians, and other trades who work in your house, who are usually subcontractors. On our jobs, we carefully select every trade partner during pre-construction to build the team for your specific project.

In North Carolina, a business with 3 or more employees has to carry workers’ compensation, so a small subcontractor may not have it. We carry it, and we check that the subcontractors on our jobs carry it too, because if a worker gets hurt and no one has coverage, they could come after you, the homeowner, for their wages. That’s from practical experience, not legal advice.

Before you sign, ask each remodeler for 3 things:

  • Written confirmation that they require all of their subcontractors to carry workers’ compensation
  • A certificate of insurance that names you as an additional insured, with general liability of at least $1 million
  • Proof that the remodeler carries workers’ compensation, too

Then ask what happens if something isn’t done right after they leave. On our jobs, if you find a problem even 6 months after we finish, call us. We’ll be responsive and take care of it; if it’s something we did wrong, we pay for it.


How Should a Remodeler Handle Costs Nobody Saw Coming?

A remodeler should tell you before you sign what can still change the price, and when something does turn up, bring you the facts and a plan.

Say the demolition crew opens a wall and finds something nobody expected, like rot from old leaks or work needed to bring things up to today’s code. In renovation work, that happens all the time, usually right after demolition exposes the framing.

Ask each remodeler what, if anything, can still change their price after you sign. Beyond changes you ask for, the list on ours is short: something hidden behind a wall or under a floor, or work an inspector asks for that’s outside the norm.

When it happens on ours, we communicate it to you in plain language, with the facts and a few possible solutions already worked out.

We’ve certainly done jobs where problems came up, and we’d like to think people judge us by how we handled them, not by the fact that they came up. So ask a remodeler’s past clients what went wrong on their job and how it got handled.


Ready to Talk Through Your Project With Watershed Builders?

We welcome this level of scrutiny. Ask us for our license, our insurance, and our references, and read our reviews. Fill out our contact form or give us a call.

author avatar
Dominick Thompson

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I ask a remodeler's past clients?

Ask how the communication was, whether the job finished on time and on budget, whether everyone was clear on what to expect, and how the remodeler handled whatever went wrong. If reviews keep coming back to good communication and a beautiful finished home, you've likely found a go-to remodeler.

Why can the lowest bid end up costing more?

A lower bid can be lower because it prices less expensive materials or leaves out parts of the job nobody accounted for. If that remodeler never had an electrician, plumber, or HVAC tech look at your house before pricing it, expect change orders once the work starts.

Read More From Watershed Builders